Christmas SALE! 10% OFF SITEWIDE  || FREE SHIPPING $75+ $50+

Enigmatic Evening: a 6 Month Small-Town Cozy Mystery

More than 1200 Letters Mailed!

  • Small Texas Town Cozy Mystery
  • Clues and Ephemera
  • 12 Letters, 6 Months, 1 Story

Emma Parker didn’t mean to get involved. But when the Brigton Gemstone vanishes, and the sheriff knocks on her bookstore door asking for help, she finds herself once again tracking patterns, reading people, and questioning everyone.

Enigmatic Evening invites you into a charming, twist-filled mystery that unravels through Emma’s eyes—her thoughts, theories, and reluctant return to investigation. Cozy, clever, and rich with small-town detail, this is storytelling you can hold in your hands.

Digital Gift Card Available for Under the Tree!

$74.99
How Would You Like the Letters:

Shipping Schedule

All at once: Ships upon purchase after January 6, 2026

One at a time: January 6, 20; February 3, 17; March 3, 17; April 7, 21; May 5, 19; and June 2, 16

Guarantee

I'm sure you will love the story, but if not, contact me within a week after receiving your first letter for a full refund. Letters purchased all at once must be returned in good condition for full refund.

 
If you love the clever village puzzles of Agatha Christie, the community spirit of Richard Osman’s Thursday Murder Club, the gentle charm of Miss Seeton, the sparkle of Her Royal Spyness, the cozy companionship of The Cat Who Series, or the small-town intrigue of Murder, She Wrote, you’ll feel right at home in Brigton. Enigmatic Evening follows Emma, the observant bookshop owner whose sharp eye draws her into the mystery of the missing Brigton Sapphire. Told through twelve letters, this cozy mystery blends gossip, secrets, and clever twists—delivered straight to your mailbox.

A quiet town. A bold theft. A reluctant sleuth.

Emma Parker didn’t mean to get involved. But when the Brigton Gemstone vanishes, and the sheriff knocks on her bookstore door asking for help, she finds herself once again tracking patterns, reading people, and questioning everyone.

Enigmatic Evening invites you into a charming, twist-filled mystery that unravels through Emma’s eyes—her thoughts, theories, and reluctant return to investigation.
- Cozy, clever, and rich with small-town detail, this is storytelling you can hold in your hands.
- Feel delight and curiosity with every letter you openReplace screen time with a cozy, story-rich ritual.

Story includes 12 long letters and multiple clues, inclusions, and ephemera related to the story.12 letters, twice a month, over 6 months.

Can you help Emma solve the mystery?

FAQs

📬 Are these real physical letters?

Yes! Each letter is printed on heavyweight 8.5×11 paper and mailed in an illustrated envelope.

🎁 What’s the difference between Weekly and All-at-Once?

Only the delivery method and schedule, the content is all the same:

  • One at a time: 1 envelope mailed on the first and third Tuesdays for 6 months. On: January 6 & 20; February 3 & 17; March 3 & 17; April 7 & 21; May 5 & 19; and June 2 & 16
  • All at Once: 1 envelope or box containing all 12 letters. Mailed at time of purchase beginning January 6, 2026.

🧁 Is Brigton real? Is this a true story?

No, while some places refrenced are real, Brigton, Emma, and all events in the story are purely fictional.

 

🐱 Do I need to read them in order?

Yes, so please let us know if one of your envelopes goes off on an adventure of its own and doesn't arrive.

Reviews from Previous Letter Stories:

Pam E.

Just thought that I would drop a line telling you how much I am enjoying my purchase. I have just received Letter #4. I also am enjoying the drawings in each letter. I can't wait for the next letter to arrive. Thanks again for the experience of each letter.

Elaine B.

I’ve planned out the next letter. Before I open it, I’m going say, “Previously on Annily’s Letters...” and read the last one again.

Paul

I absolutely love the first letter. Can't wait to read the rest of the story!! It's amazing so far!!!

Susan O

Am loving getting them through the post. Such a cute idea, and the illustrations are beautiful.

Margaret

Love these! You sure know how to keep us guessing. Can't wait for the next one.

Sharon

I'm loving getting every single letter. Can't wait for the next one to come in the mail!

Paul L.

These letters are amazing. The storyline is so so so good. I look forward to these coming in the mail.

P.L.

Love this story. I can’t wait for each letter!!!!

Elaine B.

Is anyone else getting Alice Briggs Annily letters? I got the second one and keep thinking about it. Like, it keeps popping into my mind. Those mysterious little nuggets of information have got me jonesing for the next letter. Every day I come down the stairs and stare disdainfully at the letterbox. I can see me gnawing my own arm off before the end of this. All to say, I'm enjoying it.

Mary Rosewood

This is an intriguing mystery that arrives in an exciting series of envelopes by mail. The lovely watercolor illustrations add to the enjoyment as well as the storytelling. It's really fun to get this in the mail -- I looked forward to each installment.

Paul Lawrence

I have been a subscriber for quite a while. I absolutely adore these letters. The story, the beautiful pictures, everything about this is truly beautiful. I love reading them and then the anticipation waiting for the next letter is daunting!!! When I open my mailbox and see the next letter, I jump for joy!! I love reading and seeing where the story is going next. Do yourself a favor and subscribe asap. You won’t regret it :)

Paul Lawrence

I absolutely love love getting these letters in the mail. The story is so amazing and keeps me guessing and very intrigued. I love going to the mail box and finding the next letter. So absolutely amazing!!

Javon K Pablo

Love the recipes! Tired them all. Why have I never tried hot tea with milk?!?!

Javon K Pablo

Can't believe I've never heard of this before. It is very up my alley and I have already started making my own junk journals

Javon K Pablo

Didn't realize I needed a note as I got it for myself. But I did get an instant download as well as one in the mail which was nice.

Javon K Pablo

So in love with the story and set up. This is my 3rd story thru mail. And the second one I purchased I didn't like at all. Annily introduced me to junk journaling and amazing recipes. I tired them all already. Definitely part of my self care day when I get a letter in.

$74.99
Choose Your Delivery to Purchase:
>